Shop More Submit  Join Login


Submitted on
July 9, 2013
Image Size
515 KB


371 (who?)
Hollyleaf Vs Stonefur by Dragon-In-A-Blue-Box Hollyleaf Vs Stonefur by Dragon-In-A-Blue-Box
To everyone saying that Hollyleaf is an original character and did everything she thought was right.

(BTW, this is mostly a pro-Stonefur post XD)

I noticed many similarities between the stories of Hollyleaf and Stonefur.

Stonefur is like Hollyleaf, but done right.

Stonefur went through worse scenarios, but ended up better.

Stonefur is one of the best characters in the series.

But why don't as many people like Stonefur than Hollyleaf?

I am stumped.

(I literally drew this in half an hour XD)


Guys, Hollyleaf is not a badass.
She ran away from her problems. That is the weakest and most pathetic thing someone can do.

Stonefur is a badass. He faced his problems head-on.

You like Hollyleaf because of her tragic past? Stonefur's is miles more tragic if that's all you look for in a character!
Add a Comment:
Lilac-Sun Featured By Owner 14 hours ago  New member Hobbyist Digital Artist
One word: drama.

I don't like her personally, I just drew her once since her design is really easy lmfao
rowansnoe Featured By Owner 2 days ago  Hobbyist Digital Artist
;-; Stonefur will always be better.
Superstar460 Featured By Owner 6 days ago  Hobbyist Interface Designer
I love Stonefur and hate Hollyleaf. I think the reason she's liked better is because she was seen more in the books than Stonefur. Stonefur wasn't much of a 'main character' like Holly was. Both died a 'hero' (saving Ivypool, saving Feather and Storm) and forgave their mothers before one died, so they're very similar, but Stonefur was done better. She ran away from her clan and Stone stayed and died saving his clan-mates. He should get more credit.
KatieR66 Featured By Owner Nov 9, 2014
I think the reason people like Hollyleaf better is because she has gotten more development and she was one of the main characters in the Power of Three series and she had her own Short story which is I bet you already know it's called Hollyleaf's Story which *SPOILER ALERT* developed her character and her feelings about the whole "Squirrelflight isn't my mother" thing and how she regretted trying to feed Leafpool deathberries and telling the big secret at the gathering.
Dragon-In-A-Blue-Box Featured By Owner Nov 9, 2014  Hobbyist General Artist

there's good development where the character goes through believable changes
then there's the writer trying to fit every tragic hero trope possible into one character
KatieR66 Featured By Owner Nov 9, 2014
Dragon-In-A-Blue-Box Featured By Owner Nov 10, 2014  Hobbyist General Artist
I mean, Holly had such huge potential to be a great character, but it all went down the toilet and she became a cluttered Sue-ish mess.
KatieR66 Featured By Owner Nov 10, 2014
Yeah. I wish the Erins would've devolved her more. :/
Dragon-In-A-Blue-Box Featured By Owner Nov 11, 2014  Hobbyist General Artist
Not even more
just better.
She didn't even have to be likable, they could have just made her believable but she just turned into Ebony Dark'ness Dementia Raven Way.
I could have liked Holly but she was just so horribly written it's unbelievable X'D
KatieR66 Featured By Owner Nov 11, 2014
Your point is valid and responsible.
Add a Comment: